The longest bloggernacle post of 2007 that I could find was Kevin Barney’s “On Elkenah as Canaanite El” at BCC, which was 9072 words.
It actually isn’t a post in the usual sense of the word. It was posted under the title of “BCC Papers,” and it’s clearly more like an academic paper, with two appendixes and 65 footnotes.
In Part 2 of ‘Nacle Numbers, I looked at differences in numbers and lengths of posts and comments by blog. Now, in Part 3, I’ll be looking at differences by blogger. I’ll be using the same sample of 11 blogs described in Part 1 of ‘Nacle Numbers.
About 175 bloggers wrote at least one post at one of the blogs in my sample in 2007. I reduced this number by considering only bloggers who posted at least semi-regularly, which I’ve defined as every other month, or at least 6 posts in 2007. As you’ll see, this bar is low enough to include a number of guest bloggers as well as permabloggers. The number of bloggers achieving this level of activity was 110. Well, actually, it was 106, plus 4 additional administrative accounts (e.g., BCC Admin, FMH Guest) also having at least 6 posts.
Okay, so with this list of 106 bloggers, I’ll ask the same questions I did in Part 2 about blogs.
Who wrote the most posts?
- Heather O., MMW: 190
- fMhLisa, FMH: 106
- Kaimi Wenger: T&S, 104
- The Wiz, MMW: 101
- Kevin Barney, BCC: 92
- Deborah, ExII: 91
- Geoff B, M*: 90
- RonanJH, BCC: 77
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 70
- Steve Evans, BCC: 67
Wow! Heather O. of Mormon Mommy Wars wrote nearly twice as many posts as any other blogger, more than one every other day. Following her is an unsurprising list including another MMW super-blogger (The Wiz) and some of the people known for being among the most talkative in the bloggernacle.
Of course, this is a point where the results are seriously and clearly biased by my decision to only include group blogs in the sample. Bloggers at group blogs, no matter how motivated, may be prone to social loafing. Solo bloggers, on the other hand, have nobody else to take up the slack and so may be more diligent at keeping up their blogging. Take Dave of Dave’s Mormon Inquiry, for example. He wrote 157 posts in 2007, even while taking a summer vacation and finding the time to become a permablogger at T&S and write 17 posts there. (In fact, Dave wrote an interesting post about the phenomenon of people becoming permabloggers at the big group blogs without being solo bloggers first.) Anyway, my point is that there were likely a number of solo blogger at Mormon themed blogs who out-posted many of the bloggers in this group-blog-only sample.
Who wrote the most words in posts?
- Kaimi Wenger, T&S: 54,667
- Kevin Barney, BCC: 54,447
- Heather O., MMW: 53,027
- Ardis Parshall, T&S: 45,656
- Deborah, ExII: 39,263
- Nate Oman, T&S, 36,480
- Matt W., NCT: 34,450
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 34,104
- J. Nelson-Seawright, BCC, 31,903
- fMhLisa, FMH: 31,396
One thing to note: Unfortunately, Kevin Barney’s total does not include his 9072-word treatise because it was posted under the BCC admin account. Now of course I know that he wrote it and I could include it in his total, but then to be consistent I would have to go back and check who actually wrote all the posts posted under admin accounts (like FMH’s 98 Guest posts) so I could attribute them to the right people. And really, I would have to manually check every single post, since permabloggers sometimes put guest posts up using their own accounts. All that seemed like a really big hassle for not much payoff, so I didn’t do it. 🙂
Turning to the list, using the standard of 1 Book of Mormon = 293,472 words that I introduced in Part 1 of ‘Nacle Numbers, the most prolific posters each wrote nearly 20% of a Book of Mormon in 2007.
This list of most words overlaps the list of most posts somewhat, but there are some new faces. Ardis Parshall of T&S, for example, jumped from not appearing in the top 10 for number of posts (she wrote 47) to #4 in total number of words. Such differences raise the obvious question of who wrote the longest posts.
Who wrote the longest posts (highest mean number of words)?
- Keller, M*: 1850
- J. Nelson-Seawright, BCC: 1387
- lxxluthor, FPR: 1367
- Blake, NCT: 1356
- Kevin Burtt (The Baron), M*: 1293
- amelia, ExII: 1132
- Wilfried Decoo, T&S: 1119
- Patricia Karamesines, T&S: 1083
- Maria, ExII: 1004
- Brad, BCC: 995
This is a completely different list than the previous two, with the exception of J. Nelson-Seawright of BCC who wrote both enough posts (23) and posts of enough length to also make it onto the top 10 words list above. Keller of Millennial Star had far and away the highest mean post length, with a few that look like Kevin Barney’s longest post of the year, full of footnotes and quotes, like this one about Annie Lyman.
Who wrote the longest posts (highest median number of words)?
- Keller, M*: 1404
- Kevin Burtt (The Baron), M*: 1318
- lxxluthor, FPR: 1314
- J. Nelson-Seawright, BCC: 1262
- Wilfried Decoo, T&S: 1086
- Brad, BCC: 1011
- amelia, ExII: 997
- Curtis DeGraw, T&S: 967
- Patricia Karamesines, T&S: 959
- Blake, NCT: 877
Looking at the median can show whether some bloggers have really high means because of a few long posts. This list, though, matches 8 of 10 bloggers on the highest mean list, albeit with a little reordering.
Who wrote the shortest posts (lowest mean number of words)?
- Not Ophelia, FMH: 155
- Don Clifton, Nine Moons: 209
- Rebecca, FMH: 211
- The Wiz, MMW: 241
- CJ Douglass, Nine Moons: 247
- a Random John, Mormon Mentality: 252
- Rusty, Nine Moons, 262
- Heather O., MMW: 279
- Nitsav, FPR: 288
- fMhLisa, FMH: 296
Janet of FMH once said that FMH felt “orally residual” to her, which I think means that it has some characteristics of talking rather than writing. Given that we often talk in smaller bits than we write, it makes sense that FMH bloggers would take two of the top three spots on this list of shortest posts. So this might be a list of bloggers whose blogging is most like talking. MMW and Nine Moons both placed multiple bloggers on this list, and so may be like FMH in this way. (Now Janet, please feel free to come by and set me straight about what “orally residual” really means. 🙂 )
Who wrote the shortest posts (lowest median number of words)?
- Not Ophelia, FMH: 136
- Rusty, Nine Moons: 144
- Steve Evans, BCC: 162
- a Random John, Mormon Mentality: 176
- Kristine, BCC: 180
- Rebecca, FMH: 186
- Deborah, ExII: 192
- Frank McIntrye, T&S: 193
- Matt Evans, T&S: 199
- Brooke, ExII: 200
Several bloggers appear on this list who aren’t on the shortest by mean list. This suggests that they wrote a lot of short posts, but also a few long ones that kept their means up. Steve Evans, for example, posts the Friday Firestorms; Kristine posts a lot of poetry around Easter and Christmas; Deborah posts the Virtual Oases. All of these posts tend to be short, giving these bloggers lower median post lengths than their mean post lengths, which are increased by their longer posts that don’t fall into these series.
Whose posts were the most variable in length (highest standard deviation of number of words)?
- Blake, NCT: 1470
- Keller, M*: 1231
- Kathryn Lynard Soper, T&S: 921
- Ardis Parshall, T&S: 840
- J. Nelson-Seawright, BCC: 782
- Deborah, ExII: 781
- lxxluthor, FPR: 760
- Russell Arben Fox, T&S: 739
- john f., Mormon Mentality: 695
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 691
Four of the 10 bloggers on this list are also on the longest mean list. This suggests that even the most verbose bloggers sometimes wrote posts of more typical lengths, pushing their standard deviations up. But there are also several bloggers who aren’t on the highest mean list, 4 of them from T&S, and their posts do vary in length to a degree that surprised me. Ardis Parshall and Julie M. Smith, for example, wrote both lengthy posts (see Ardis’s “Of Perfect Organizations” or Julie’s “In Defense of Commentaries“) complete with headings, quotes, and footnotes, as well as brief conversation starter-type posts (see Ardis’s “Have You Read All These Books?” or Julie’s “Does Seminary Make Kids Fat and Stupid?“).
Whose posts were the least variable in length (lowest standard deviation of number of words)?
- Don Clifton, Nine Moons: 89
- Tagore, Mormon Mentality: 108
- Devyn S., Mormon Mentality: 116
- Rebecca, FMH: 144
- CJ Douglass, Nine Moons: 152
- Starfoxy, FMH/T&S: 157
- Not Ophelia, FMH: 180
- Amri Brown, BCC: 193
- ECS, FMH: 196
- Tracy M, MMW/BCC: 197
I would have guessed before checking that the bloggers whose posts were of the most consistent length simply wrote very few posts and had little chance to deviate from their usual. But this isn’t the case. Don Clifton wrote 33 posts. Devyn S. wrote 34. Rebecca wrote 56! It is the case, though, that the bloggers on this list tended to write fairly short posts. Only Starfoxy (562) and Amri Brown (537) had mean lengths over 400 words. I guess it’s easier to write consistently shorter posts than consistently long ones.
Whose longest posts had the most words?
- Deborah, ExII: 6909
- Blake, NCT: 5249
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 4879
- Kaimi Wenger, T&S: 4777
- Keller, M*: 4083
- J. Nelson-Seawright, BCC: 4025
- Ardis Parshall, T&S: 3833
- lxxluthor, FPR: 3181
- Kathryn Lynard Soper, T&S: 3170
- Kevin Barney, BCC: 3023
Note that this isn’t necessarily a list of the ten longest posts. It’s a list of the ten bloggers whose longest posts were the longest. It may be, for example, that Kaimi wrote 5 more posts over 4000 words in addition to his longest, but they’re not included because they’re not his longest (I haven’t checked). Also recall that Kevin Barney’s 9072-word post doesn’t appear on the list because it was posted under the BCC Admin account, and these lists don’t include posts under administrative accounts. He makes the list anyway, though, with a 3023-word post that I’m sure was child’s play for him. 🙂
Now that I’ve shown you top 10 lists, let me show you results for all 106 bloggers. In the pink-topped tables below you’ll find each blogger’s total number of posts, total words in posts, mean, median, standard deviation, and maximum words.
A few notes about the tables:
- Bloggers are listed by their blogs. Bloggers who posted at more than one blog are listed at the blog where they posted the most. Footnotes below the tables tell how many posts they wrote at each blog.
- Blogs are ordered by their total number of posts. Note that the sum of the individual bloggers’ numbers of posts and words won’t necessarily add to the totals for the blogs in Part 2 of ‘Nacle Numbers because of the exclusion of bloggers who wrote fewer than 6 posts.
- Bloggers are ordered within each blog by their total number of posts.
- Values among the highest 10 in the lists above are highlighted with yellow. Values among the lowest 10 are highlighted with green.
- Within each blog, the highest value for each variable (e.g., number of posts) is bolded. The lowest value is italicized.
- Administrative accounts are not included in choosing highest and lowest values. Their names appear in brackets: [Guest].
By Common Consent | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Kevin Barney | 92 | 54,447 | 592 | 482 | 454 | 3023 |
RonanJH | 77 | 28,338 | 368 | 319 | 359 | 1861 |
Steve Evans | 67 | 20,834 | 311 | 162 | 391 | 1833 |
Sam MB | 65 | 26,549 | 408 | 324 | 275 | 1080 |
J. Daniel Crawford1 | 41 | 20,130 | 491 | 433 | 306 | 1180 |
Kristine | 41 | 12,857 | 314 | 180 | 388 | 1934 |
Mark Brown | 40 | 25,277 | 632 | 601 | 402 | 2541 |
J. Stapley | 34 | 20,317 | 598 | 563 | 257 | 1316 |
Norbert | 30 | 13,642 | 455 | 438 | 201 | 1159 |
J. Nelson-Seawright | 23 | 31,903 | 1387 | 1262 | 782 | 4025 |
[Guest] | 16 | 13,668 | 854 | 707 | 493 | 2133 |
Amri Brown | 16 | 8,592 | 537 | 543 | 193 | 788 |
Natalie | 15 | 8664 | 578 | 577 | 277 | 1043 |
Aaron B | 14 | 10,472 | 748 | 723 | 536 | 1719 |
Stirling | 11 | 8,126 | 739 | 522 | 583 | 1918 |
Melissa De Leon Mason | 10 | 5,793 | 579 | 579 | 270 | 926 |
Taryn Nelson-Seawrighta | 8 | 4,439 | 555 | 347 | 505 | 1532 |
[BCC Admin] | 6 | 12,496 | 2083 | 43 | 3669 | 9072 |
Brad | 6 | 5,972 | 995 | 1011 | 348 | 1501 |
S.P. Bailey | 6 | 3,575 | 596 | 515 | 431 | 1424 |
Kris | 6 | 2,709 | 451 | 419 | 388 | 978 |
1This includes 35 posts at BCC and 6 at FPR.
aThis includes 6 posts at BCC and 2 at FMH.
Times and Seasons | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Kaimi Wenger | 104 | 54,667 | 526 | 371 | 670 | 4777 |
Julie M. Smith | 70 | 34,104 | 487 | 312 | 691 | 4879 |
Adam Greenwoodb | 59 | 18,471 | 313 | 210 | 374 | 2276 |
Nate Oman | 56 | 36,480 | 651 | 563 | 467 | 2119 |
Ardis Parshall | 47 | 45,656 | 971 | 711 | 840 | 3833 |
Jonathan Green | 45 | 27,961 | 621 | 577 | 346 | 1499 |
Russell Arben Fox | 37 | 25,815 | 698 | 337 | 739 | 2786 |
Dave Banack | 17 | 10,549 | 621 | 628 | 289 | 1200 |
Patricia Karamesines | 16 | 17,324 | 1083 | 959 | 507 | 2515 |
Kathryn Lynard Soper | 16 | 12,101 | 756 | 501 | 921 | 3170 |
Jim F. | 13 | 7,727 | 594 | 531 | 418 | 1590 |
Matt Evans | 13 | 5,265 | 405 | 199 | 632 | 2458 |
Frank McIntyre | 13 | 4,693 | 361 | 193 | 371 | 1121 |
Wilfried Decoo | 9 | 10,073 | 1119 | 1086 | 604 | 2033 |
Rosalynde Welch | 9 | 6,862 | 763 | 594 | 522 | 1997 |
Curtis DeGraw | 7 | 6,417 | 917 | 967 | 311 | 1260 |
Ben Huff | 7 | 4,154 | 593 | 610 | 448 | 1330 |
bThis includes 57 posts at T&S and 2 at M*.
Feminist Mormon Housewives | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
fMhLisa | 106 | 31,396 | 296 | 223 | 259 | 1313 |
[Guest] | 98 | 68,171 | 696 | 550 | 522 | 2819 |
Rebecca | 56 | 11,827 | 211 | 186 | 144 | 981 |
Artemis | 47 | 21,054 | 448 | 393 | 397 | 1755 |
ECS | 27 | 8,433 | 312 | 256 | 196 | 682 |
Janet | 24 | 13,028 | 543 | 501 | 337 | 1180 |
Quimby | 24 | 11,609 | 484 | 358 | 404 | 1618 |
EmilyS | 21 | 12,685 | 604 | 559 | 408 | 1992 |
Starfoxyc | 10 | 5,622 | 562 | 575 | 157 | 795 |
G | 8 | 4,271 | 534 | 575 | 264 | 987 |
JohnRd | 8 | 3,714 | 464 | 535 | 232 | 763 |
LAGirrrl | 7 | 4,447 | 635 | 526 | 431 | 1515 |
Not Ophelia | 7 | 1,086 | 155 | 136 | 180 | 530 |
cThis includes 6 posts at FMH and 4 at T&S.
dThis includes 7 posts at FMH and 1 at ExII.
Mormon Mommy Wars | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Heather O.e | 190 | 53,027 | 279 | 265 | 204 | 921 |
The Wiz | 101 | 24,328 | 241 | 224 | 209 | 1291 |
Tracy Mf | 47 | 14,168 | 301 | 269 | 197 | 1026 |
Hollywood | 39 | 17,238 | 442 | 434 | 249 | 1315 |
eThis includes 189 posts at MMW and 1 at FMH.
fThis includes 33 posts at MMW and 14 at BCC.
Mormon Mentality | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
DKL | 58 | 29,843 | 515 | 450 | 447 | 2506 |
annegb | 53 | 26,320 | 497 | 399 | 465 | 2330 |
danithew | 48 | 14,822 | 309 | 273 | 205 | 1048 |
a Random John | 35 | 8,816 | 252 | 176 | 238 | 1036 |
Devyn S. | 34 | 11,871 | 349 | 334 | 116 | 547 |
Matt B | 29 | 19,708 | 680 | 664 | 466 | 1654 |
Proud Daughter of Eve | 22 | 7,867 | 358 | 272 | 264 | 1121 |
Tagore | 19 | 7,368 | 388 | 381 | 108 | 591 |
Dan Ellsworth | 18 | 10,144 | 564 | 613 | 286 | 1102 |
Margaret Youngg | 17 | 11,590 | 682 | 613 | 293 | 1396 |
john f. | 13 | 11,754 | 904 | 745 | 695 | 2335 |
Amira | 10 | 3,471 | 347 | 327 | 211 | 853 |
Wayne L. | 8 | 6,805 | 851 | 766 | 441 | 1633 |
gThis includes 6 posts at Mormon Mentality, 6 at T&S, and 5 at BCC.
Exponent II | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Deborah | 91 | 39,263 | 431 | 192 | 781 | 6909 |
EmilyCC | 39 | 28,204 | 723 | 565 | 593 | 2478 |
Caroline | 34 | 18,649 | 549 | 507 | 337 | 1758 |
jana | 21 | 9,995 | 476 | 289 | 520 | 2204 |
Dora | 17 | 13,392 | 788 | 847 | 380 | 1576 |
AmyB | 15 | 10,260 | 684 | 568 | 464 | 1997 |
Maria | 13 | 13,056 | 1004 | 793 | 526 | 2207 |
Brooke | 13 | 4,188 | 322 | 200 | 233 | 870 |
ameliah | 11 | 12,456 | 1132 | 997 | 489 | 2333 |
hThis includes 8 posts at ExII and 3 at FMH.
Millennial Star | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Geoff B | 90 | 28,558 | 317 | 237 | 271 | 1001 |
John Mansfield | 34 | 11,053 | 325 | 228 | 286 | 1147 |
Brian D. | 29 | 13,618 | 470 | 427 | 315 | 1183 |
Ivan Wolfe | 16 | 7,853 | 491 | 376 | 411 | 1508 |
Kevin Burtt (The Baron) | 15 | 19,402 | 1293 | 1318 | 639 | 2426 |
Keller | 11 | 20,347 | 1850 | 1404 | 1231 | 4083 |
Sarah | 7 | 4657 | 665 | 637 | 244 | 1063 |
Nine Moons | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Rusty | 64 | 16,769 | 262 | 144 | 389 | 2851 |
Don Clifton | 33 | 6,888 | 209 | 211 | 89 | 369 |
Susan M | 30 | 12,688 | 423 | 332 | 383 | 2046 |
Tom | 17 | 9,373 | 551 | 527 | 285 | 1087 |
Lamonte | 14 | 9,857 | 704 | 696 | 305 | 1422 |
Seth | 13 | 7,431 | 572 | 589 | 260 | 1107 |
CJ Douglass | 11 | 2,720 | 247 | 229 | 152 | 515 |
Faith Promoting Rumor | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
TT | 49 | 23,011 | 470 | 450 | 312 | 1494 |
smallaxe | 26 | 8,333 | 320 | 247 | 308 | 1567 |
Nitsav | 25 | 7,202 | 288 | 212 | 265 | 1157 |
lxxluthor | 18 | 24,607 | 1367 | 1314 | 760 | 3181 |
Mogget | 11 | 9,609 | 874 | 728 | 672 | 2383 |
jupiterschild | 9 | 5,363 | 596 | 632 | 255 | 1004 |
Chris H. | 6 | 3,887 | 648 | 698 | 431 | 1116 |
New Cool Thang | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Matt W. | 63 | 34,450 | 547 | 522 | 419 | 1794 |
Geoff J | 41 | 20,272 | 494 | 399 | 354 | 1551 |
Jacob J | 28 | 25,748 | 920 | 840 | 514 | 2427 |
Blake | 9 | 12,205 | 1356 | 877 | 1470 | 5249 |
Kristen J | 8 | 4,906 | 613 | 487 | 314 | 1237 |
Zelophehad’s Daughters | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Posts | Words in Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | ||
Lynnette | 26 | 19,540 | 752 | 690 | 357 | 1789 |
Eve | 19 | 14,888 | 784 | 806 | 337 | 1339 |
Ziff | 13 | 9,084 | 699 | 545 | 604 | 2091 |
Seraphine | 13 | 8,628 | 664 | 770 | 246 | 958 |
Kiskilili | 12 | 10,459 | 872 | 867 | 335 | 1466 |
Vada | 9 | 4,725 | 525 | 444 | 210 | 854 |
[ZD] | 8 | 790 | 99 | 50 | 114 | 348 |
Now let’s look at number of comments broken down by post author.
Whose posts drew the most total comments?
- fMhLisa, FMH: 5561
- Steve Evans, BCC: 5297
- RonanJH, BCC: 4954
- Kaimi Wenger, T&S: 4822
- Kevin Barney, BCC: 4249
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 3848
- Heather O., MMW: 3667
- Geoff J, NCT: 2715
- Geoff B, M*: 2553
- J. Daniel Crawford, BCC/FPR: 2474
Comparing this list to the second table in Part 2 of ‘Nacle Numbers, it appears that fMhLisa, Steve Evans, Ronan, and Kaimi each drew more comments individually than did the entire blogs Nine Moons, M*, ZD, FPR, or ExII.
Also, as you’ll see in the tables below, the FMH guest account, had it been included, would have been #1 with 5901 comments on 98 posts. They sure do know how to attract lots of interesting guest posts at FMH. So many that mfranti was recently appointed as the organizational keeper of the guest posts, which I hope means even more guest posts will appear in 2008.
Whose posts drew the most comments (highest mean)?
- JohnR, FMH: 124
- ECS, FMH: 85
- Steve Evans, BCC: 79
- Aaron B, BCC: 71
- Matt Evans, T&S: 70 (70.31)
- Devyn S., Mormon Mentality: 70 (70.27)
- Geoff J, NCT: 66 (66.22)
- Russell Arben Fox, T&S: 66 (65.87)
- G, FMH: 65
- RonanJH, BCC: 64
It looks like JohnR really stirred up some discussion during his stint at FMH–124 comments per post–nearly half as many more as the #2 person (although ECS did write 27 posts to his 8). G, at #9, is also an FMH guest blogger. So not only do the one-time guest posters at FMH draw a lot of discussion, the people who formally guest blog there do also.
Whose posts drew the most comments (highest median)?
- JohnR, FMH: 102
- ECS, FMH: 77
- Steve Evans, BCC: 72
- Matt Evans, T&S: 67 (67.0)
- Aaron B, BCC: 59
- G, FMH: 54
- RonanJH, BCC: 51
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 48
- Rosalynde Welch, T&S: 46
- [tie] Mark Brown, BCC and Blake, NCT: 45
This is largely the same list, with Ronan, Julie, and Rosalynde replacing Devyn S., Geoff J, and Russell Arben Fox. Not surprisingly, on this list, which probably best captures number of comments per post, other thank Blake of NCT tied at #10, everyone is from the big three blogs.
Whose posts drew the fewest comments (lowest mean)?
- Deborah, ExII: 6 (5.88)
- Brooke, ExII: 6 (6.15)
- EmilyCC, ExII: 6 (6.26)
- Keller, M*: 7
- Amira, Mormon Mentality: 8 (8.10)
- Sarah, M*: 8 (8.29)
- Kevin Burtt (The Baron), M*: 11 (10.80)
- Dora, ExII: 11 (11.12)
- Brian Duffin, M*: 12
- John Mansfield, M*: 14
You can get at least a vague idea of what people post about by number of comments. Deborah’s virtual oases, Brooke’s poetry, and EmilyCC’s recipes, for example, are more FYE (for your edification) than comment-inducing (argument-inciting?) topics more common among the bloggers who draw lots of comments.
(In the tables below, you’ll see that AmyB of ExII also had a mean of 14, but hers was actually 14.20 while John Mansfield’s was 13.71.)
Whose posts drew the fewest comments (lowest median)?
- 1. Deborah, ExII: 3
- [tie] EmilyCC, ExII: 3
- 3. Chris H., FPR: 4
- 4. Brooke, ExII: 5
- 5. jana, ExII: 6
- [tie] Rebecca, FMH: 6
- 7. Amira, Mormon Mentality: 7
- [tie] Keller, M*: 7
- 9. John Mansfield, M*: 8
- 10. Dora, ExII: 9
- [tie] jupiterschild, FPR: 9
- [tie] Sarah, M*: 9
Sorry about the kludgey look; I couldn’t get a numbered list to allow for ties.
Whose posts drew the most variable number of comments (highest standard deviation)?
- Devyn S., Mormon Mentality: 117
- Russell Arben Fox, T&S: 93
- JohnR, FMH: 91
- amelia, ExII: 83
- Geoff J, NCT: 79
- Seraphine, ZD: 77
- ECS, FMH: 72
- Steve Evans, BCC: 61
- Kris, BCC: 60
- J. Nelson-Seawright, BCC: 58
Devyn S. had the highest standard deviation far and away, I think largely because when you write a post that draws 650 comments (637 at the time I gathered data), it really pushes your standard deviation up. I think at least some of the other bloggers on the list also have high standard deviations because of a few posts that drew a whole bunch of comments. Russell Arben Fox, for example, typically posts the T&S General Conference open threads, and these sometimes draw hundreds of comments.
Whose posts drew the least variable number of comments (lowest standard deviation)?
- Keller, M*: 4 (3.70)
- Sarah, M*: 4 (4.27)
- Brooke, ExII: 4 (4.49)
- Amira, Mormon Mentality: 5
- Dora, ExII: 8 (7.77)
- Kevin Burtt (The Baron), M*: 8 (7.80)
- EmilyCC, ExII: 9 (8.68)
- LAGirrrl, FMH: 9 (9.01)
- Deborah, ExII: 9 (9.10)
- Proud Daughter of Eve, Mormon Mentality: 11
This list largely overlaps with the “fewest comments” lists.
Whose most-commented-on post drew the most comments?
- Devyn S., Mormon Mentality: 637
- Russell Arben Fox, T&S: 449
- Geoff J, NCT: 410
- ECS, FMH: 329
- fMhLisa, FMH: 318
- JohnR, FMH: 316
- amelia, ExII: 290
- Seraphine, ZD: 283
- Steve Evans, BCC: 251
- Lynnette, ZD: 249
There’s Devyn S.’s “Married Mormon Graduate Students on Welfare” post with 600+ comments. Russell Arben’s Fox’s #2 was the Conference Open Thread for the session in which President Beck delivered her “Mothers Who Know” talk. (fMhLisa’s #5 also addressed President Beck’s talk.) Geoff J at #3, Seraphine at #8, and Lynnette at #10 were all part of one big long argument discussion. ECS’s most-commented was her comparison of President Benson’s and President Hinckley’s statements on mothers working outside the home. JohnR’s #6 was “The Loneliness of the Male Feminist.” Amelia’s #7 was a guest post at FMH, “the rhetoric of marriage, or please tell me why.” Steve Evans’s #9 was “The Priesthood Ban and Infallibility,” but he had lots of other posts with similarly high numbers of comments, such as “Your Home Teacher Tortures Inmates” and two consecutive Friday Firestorms in December, for example.
This whole topic of what kinds of posts draw the most comments is so interesting that, as jjohnson suggested, I’m going to write an entire post on it soon (or at least start one–I might not finish it).
Here are the results for all 106 bloggers. In the blue-topped tables are the total number of comments on each blogger’s posts, as well as the mean, median, standard deviation, and maximum. In these tables, blogs are ordered by their total number of comments, as are bloggers within blogs.
As in the previous tables, values among the highest 10 in the lists above are highlighted with yellow. Values among the lowest 10 are highlighted with green. Within each blog, the highest value for each variable (e.g., number of comments) is bolded. The lowest value is italicized.
By Common Consent | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Steve Evans | 5297 | 79 | 72 | 61 | 251 |
RonanJH | 4954 | 64 | 51 | 48 | 242 |
Kevin Barney | 4249 | 46 | 27 | 46 | 226 |
J. Daniel Crawford | 2474 | 60 | 37 | 52 | 187 |
Sam MB | 2079 | 32 | 23 | 28 | 112 |
Mark Brown | 1796 | 45 | 45 | 27 | 104 |
J. Nelson-Seawright | 1451 | 63 | 42 | 58 | 233 |
J. Stapley | 1249 | 37 | 31 | 29 | 136 |
[Guest] | 1061 | 66 | 40 | 73 | 222 |
Norbert | 991 | 33 | 29 | 22 | 110 |
Aaron B | 990 | 71 | 59 | 50 | 175 |
Amri Brown | 893 | 56 | 41 | 35 | 145 |
Kristine | 810 | 20 | 12 | 32 | 193 |
Natalie | 667 | 44 | 33 | 37 | 132 |
Stirling | 489 | 44 | 37 | 41 | 122 |
Melissa De Leon Mason | 416 | 42 | 36 | 25 | 81 |
Taryn Nelson-Seawright | 391 | 49 | 39 | 47 | 149 |
Kris | 380 | 63 | 34 | 60 | 175 |
[BCC Admin] | 285 | 48 | 37 | 30 | 94 |
Brad | 252 | 42 | 21 | 40 | 108 |
S.P. Bailey | 165 | 28 | 28 | 14 | 50 |
Times and Seasons | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Kaimi Wenger | 4822 | 46 | 33 | 41 | 213 |
Julie M. Smith | 3848 | 55 | 48 | 49 | 244 |
Russell Arben Fox | 2437 | 66 | 23 | 93 | 449 |
Adam Greenwood | 2016 | 34 | 23 | 32 | 128 |
Nate Oman | 1770 | 32 | 24 | 26 | 142 |
Jonathan Green | 1706 | 38 | 31 | 36 | 215 |
Ardis Parshall | 1527 | 32 | 25 | 35 | 228 |
Matt Evans | 914 | 70 | 67 | 51 | 191 |
Kathryn Lynard Soper | 814 | 51 | 44 | 37 | 117 |
Dave Banack | 784 | 46 | 37 | 29 | 98 |
Patricia Karamesines | 713 | 45 | 40 | 27 | 103 |
Frank McIntyre | 586 | 45 | 41 | 30 | 112 |
Rosalynde Welch | 452 | 50 | 46 | 37 | 129 |
Wilfried Decoo | 359 | 40 | 33 | 29 | 116 |
Curtis DeGraw | 253 | 36 | 23 | 31 | 91 |
Jim F. | 250 | 19 | 18 | 17 | 55 |
Ben Huff | 213 | 30 | 24 | 27 | 82 |
Feminist Mormon Housewives | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
[Guest] | 5901 | 60 | 44 | 71 | 467 |
fMhLisa | 5561 | 52 | 37 | 54 | 318 |
ECS | 2291 | 85 | 77 | 72 | 329 |
Artemis | 1854 | 39 | 23 | 47 | 213 |
EmilyS | 1236 | 59 | 35 | 57 | 223 |
Quimby | 1228 | 51 | 36 | 40 | 160 |
Rebecca | 1076 | 19 | 6 | 33 | 203 |
JohnR | 994 | 124 | 102 | 91 | 316 |
Janet | 960 | 40 | 30 | 34 | 137 |
G | 523 | 65 | 54 | 36 | 114 |
Starfoxy | 410 | 41 | 42 | 21 | 71 |
Not Ophelia | 184 | 26 | 17 | 32 | 84 |
LAGirrrl | 146 | 21 | 20 | 9 | 35 |
Mormon Mentality | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Devyn S. | 2389 | 70 | 39 | 117 | 637 |
DKL | 1785 | 31 | 23 | 25 | 102 |
annegb | 1592 | 30 | 19 | 29 | 120 |
danithew | 1028 | 21 | 16 | 20 | 105 |
a Random John | 978 | 28 | 18 | 27 | 123 |
Margaret Young | 825 | 49 | 37 | 38 | 141 |
Tagore | 739 | 39 | 37 | 16 | 73 |
Matt B | 733 | 25 | 17 | 28 | 150 |
Dan Ellsworth | 709 | 39 | 25 | 46 | 170 |
john f. | 495 | 38 | 23 | 40 | 145 |
Proud Daughter of Eve | 399 | 18 | 15 | 11 | 40 |
Wayne L. | 155 | 19 | 14 | 15 | 48 |
Amira | 81 | 8 | 7 | 5 | 18 |
Mormon Mommy Wars | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Heather O. | 3667 | 19 | 17 | 16 | 112 |
The Wiz | 2332 | 23 | 16 | 27 | 219 |
Tracy M | 1228 | 26 | 20 | 27 | 175 |
Hollywood | 991 | 25 | 22 | 18 | 85 |
New Cool Thang | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Geoff J | 2715 | 66 | 39 | 79 | 410 |
Matt W. | 2043 | 32 | 22 | 34 | 216 |
Jacob J | 987 | 35 | 25 | 29 | 112 |
Blake | 538 | 60 | 45 | 44 | 134 |
Kristen J | 179 | 22 | 21 | 12 | 43 |
Nine Moons | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Rusty | 1877 | 29 | 23 | 25 | 121 |
Don Clifton | 587 | 18 | 15 | 16 | 91 |
Tom | 553 | 33 | 22 | 31 | 122 |
Susan M | 449 | 15 | 11 | 12 | 46 |
Seth | 325 | 25 | 23 | 14 | 54 |
Lamonte | 314 | 22 | 14 | 20 | 65 |
CJ Douglass | 200 | 18 | 14 | 20 | 74 |
Millennial Star | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Geoff B | 2553 | 28 | 17 | 30 | 162 |
John Mansfield | 466 | 14 | 8 | 17 | 88 |
Ivan Wolfe | 427 | 27 | 23 | 26 | 100 |
Brian Duffin | 339 | 12 | 10 | 12 | 61 |
Kevin Burtt (The Baron) | 162 | 11 | 10 | 8 | 28 |
Keller | 78 | 7 | 7 | 4 | 15 |
Sarah | 58 | 8 | 9 | 4 | 15 |
Zelophehad’s Daughters | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Lynnette | 880 | 34 | 21 | 47 | 249 |
Seraphine | 768 | 59 | 25 | 77 | 283 |
Kiskilili | 563 | 47 | 34 | 52 | 202 |
Eve | 458 | 24 | 17 | 15 | 55 |
Ziff | 352 | 27 | 24 | 22 | 94 |
Vada | 333 | 37 | 19 | 35 | 112 |
[ZD] | 82 | 10 | 6 | 12 | 26 |
Faith Promoting Rumor | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
TT | 1047 | 21 | 11 | 25 | 106 |
lxxluthor | 504 | 28 | 19 | 24 | 80 |
smallaxe | 418 | 16 | 11 | 15 | 62 |
Nitsav | 369 | 15 | 11 | 17 | 85 |
Mogget | 266 | 24 | 12 | 20 | 55 |
jupiterschild | 184 | 20 | 9 | 19 | 57 |
Chris H. | 99 | 17 | 4 | 22 | 56 |
Exponent II | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Caroline | 792 | 23 | 21 | 15 | 54 |
Deborah | 535 | 6 | 3 | 9 | 52 |
amelia | 451 | 41 | 16 | 83 | 290 |
jana | 343 | 16 | 6 | 25 | 113 |
Maria | 257 | 20 | 17 | 12 | 39 |
EmilyCC | 244 | 6 | 3 | 9 | 45 |
AmyB | 213 | 14 | 11 | 12 | 40 |
Dora | 189 | 11 | 9 | 8 | 36 |
Brooke | 80 | 6 | 5 | 4 | 17 |
Finally, here are some top ten lists for length of comments on each blogger’s posts.
Whose posts received the most total words in comments?
- fMhLisa, FMH: 592,690
- Kaimi Wenger, T&S: 471,420
- Steve Evans, BCC: 415,822
- Julie M. Smith, T&S: 414,430
- RonanJH, BCC: 412,337
- Kevin Barney, BCC: 341,082
- Geoff J, NCT: 334,710
- Geoff B, M*: 316,920
- ECS, FMH: 274,485
- Devyn S., Mormon Mentality: 270,637
Just to make sure I’m clear, this isn’t the number of words each blogger wrote in comments, but rather the number of words of comments written on the blogger’s posts. So for example, all commenters on fMhLisa’s posts collectively wrote 592,690 words of comments. That’s about two Books of Mormon worth.
Whose posts received the longest comments (highest mean)?
- Keller, M*: 191
- Kiskilili, ZD: 171
- JohnR, FMH: 158 (158.00)
- Wayne L., Mormon Mentality: 158 (157.64)
- Vada, ZD: 153
- Lynnette, ZD: 150 (150.22)
- Dora, ExII: 150 (150.04)
- amelia, ExII: 150 (149.93)
- Blake, NCT: 147
- Seraphine, ZD: 146
Keller of M* shows up on a lot of these lists. It appears that he writes very long posts that draw a small number of comments, but those comments are also really long. JohnR also appears high on the list here just as he did for number of comments. So he not only drew lots of comments, he also drew long comments. Several of my ZD co-bloggers also show up here as inducing people to write really long comments. Admit it, Kiskilili, Vada, Lynnette, and Seraphine! You stay up nights thinking of inflammatory posts to write just to see what great lengths people will go to to refute you.
Whose posts received the longest comments (highest median)?
- Dora, ExII: 125
- Kiskilili, ZD: 123
- Vada, ZD: 118
- Seraphine, ZD: 115
- amelia, ExII: 110
- Lynnette, ZD: 108
- JohnR, FMH: 107 (107.0)
- AmyB, ExII: 107 (106.5)
- Wayne L., Mormon Mentality: 105
- smallaxe, FPR: 101
This is largely the same list, although with some re-ordering that makes it really dominated by representatives of the feminacle.
Whose posts received the shortest comments (lowest mean)?
- Kristine, BCC: 55
- Russell Arben Fox, T&S: 62 (61.81)
- Kristen J, NCT: 62 (62.03)
- The Wiz, MMW: 67
- Tagore, Mormon Mentality: 70
- Heather O., MMW: 73
- Amira, Mormon Mentality: 73
- a Random John, Mormon Mentality: 74
- Hollywood, MMW: 75 (75.12)
- Brian Duffin, M*: 75 (75.25)
You might say this list is dominated by MMW bloggers, as three of their four permabloggers show up on it. This matches my (admittedly limited) experience with MMW: it’s more like a chat than a place where people fire 1000-word treatises back and forth.
(Note that if you read the tables below, you’ll find that J. Stapley of BCC and Nitsav of FPR also had means that rounded to 75, but their actual means were 75.34 and 75.37, so they just missed the list.)
Whose posts received the shortest comments (lowest median)?
- Russell Arben Fox, T&S: 27
- Kristine, BCC: 29
- Nitsav, FPR: 41
- Kristen J, NCT: 42
- Amira, Mormon Mentality: 43
- The Wiz, MMW: 45
- Susan M, Nine Moons: 46 (46.0)
- Rusty, Nine Moons: 46 (46.2)
- Brian Duffin, M*: 47 (46.5)
- Curtis DeGraw, T&S: 47 (46.7)
I wonder if Russell Arben Fox’s comment lengths weren’t affected by the Conference Open Thread posts. This wouldn’t be surprising given that these means and medians are based on all comments on a bloggers posts, not aggregated as the mean of means across posts or anything like that. So his comment lengths are likely dominated by the very brief comments typically written during Conference.
(Note that Steve Evans of BCC also had a median that rounded to 47, but it was actually 47.2.)
Whose posts drew comments of most variable length?
- Keller, M*: 273
- Patricia Karamesines, T&S: 186
- Blake, NCT: 185
- Ben Huff, T&S: 180
- Stirling, BCC: 176
- Wayne L., Mormon Mentality: 175
- JohnR, FMH: 172
- Lynnette, ZD: 170
- Kiskilili, ZD: 166
- lxxluthor, FPR: 165
Whose posts drew comments of least variable length?
- Kristen J, NCT: 64
- Hollywood, MMW: 69
- Tagore, Mormon Mentality: 70
- The Wiz, MMW: 74
- Heather O., MMW: 75
- J. Stapley, BCC: 76 (75.82)
- Kristine, BCC: 76 (76.35)
- Amira, Mormon Mentality: 82
- Wilfried Decoo, T&S: 84
- a Random John, Mormon Mentality: 85 (84.72)
I’m not sure that these lists have much to say, as they largely replicate the longest and shortest average lists. This suggests that all bloggers receive some short comments, as those whose means and medians are higher also have standard deviations that are higher.
(Note that a Random John’s standard deviation was 84.72, just beating out fellow blogger danithew (85.08) and Nitsav of FPR (85.09), whose standard deviations also round to 85 in the tables below.)
Whose longest comment received was the longest?
- fMhLisa, FMH: 3404
- Kevin Barney, BCC: 2769
- Frank McIntyre, T&S: 2481
- Devyn S., Mormon Mentality: 2449
- Tracy M, MMW/BCC: 2187
- Geoff B, M*: 2090
- Adam Greenwood, T&S: 2089
- Stirling, BCC: 1973
- Lynnette, ZD: 1915
- Blake, NCT: 1856
I know it would be much more interesting to know who actually wrote these ultra-long comments rather than whose posts they were written in response to. I’ll present some data on commenters in a future post.
Finally, here are the results for all 106 bloggers. In the gray-topped tables are the total number of words in comments on each blogger’s posts, as well as the mean, median, standard deviation, and maximum. In these tables, blogs are ordered by their total number of words in comments, as are bloggers within blogs.
As in the previous tables, values among the highest 10 in the lists above are highlighted with yellow. Values among the lowest 10 are highlighted with green. Within each blog, the highest value for each variable (e.g., total words in comments) is bolded. The lowest value is italicized.
By Common Consent | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Steve Evans | 415,822 | 79 | 47 | 92 | 1046 |
RonanJH | 412,337 | 83 | 50 | 96 | 1162 |
Kevin Barney | 341,082 | 80 | 51 | 104 | 2769 |
J. Daniel Crawford | 224,557 | 91 | 51 | 120 | 1467 |
Sam MB | 200,285 | 96 | 64 | 108 | 1147 |
Mark Brown | 168,259 | 94 | 65 | 99 | 1211 |
J. Nelson-Seawright | 165,518 | 114 | 77 | 126 | 1474 |
Aaron B | 102,824 | 104 | 78 | 97 | 745 |
[Guest] | 101,262 | 95 | 66 | 98 | 713 |
J. Stapley | 94,100 | 75 | 53 | 76 | 556 |
Norbert | 88,307 | 89 | 60 | 96 | 766 |
Amri Brown | 83,664 | 94 | 65 | 95 | 1083 |
Natalie | 68,804 | 103 | 78 | 99 | 771 |
Stirling | 48,099 | 98 | 51 | 176 | 1973 |
Kristine | 44,343 | 55 | 29 | 76 | 793 |
Melissa De Leon Mason | 42,558 | 102 | 70 | 107 | 857 |
Taryn Nelson-Seawright | 40,484 | 104 | 67 | 126 | 1636 |
Kris | 34,286 | 90 | 64 | 102 | 659 |
Brad | 27,363 | 109 | 63 | 119 | 604 |
[BCC Admin] | 17,582 | 62 | 25 | 145 | 2021 |
S.P. Bailey | 16,596 | 101 | 64 | 100 | 517 |
Feminist Mormon Housewives | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
[Guest] | 757,488 | 128 | 88 | 137 | 2139 |
fMhLisa | 592,690 | 107 | 68 | 128 | 3404 |
ECS | 274,485 | 120 | 86 | 120 | 1091 |
Artemis | 186,842 | 101 | 67 | 105 | 940 |
JohnR | 157,049 | 158 | 107 | 172 | 1295 |
EmilyS | 153,692 | 124 | 91 | 120 | 1181 |
Quimby | 147,323 | 120 | 88 | 117 | 1314 |
Rebecca | 114,749 | 107 | 72 | 111 | 865 |
Janet | 106,968 | 111 | 72 | 124 | 1098 |
G | 61,483 | 118 | 81 | 122 | 1224 |
Starfoxy | 49,748 | 121 | 95 | 109 | 819 |
Not Ophelia | 23,405 | 127 | 74 | 153 | 1140 |
LAGirrrl | 17,853 | 122 | 63 | 136 | 766 |
Times and Seasons | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Kaimi Wenger | 471,420 | 98 | 58 | 121 | 1639 |
Julie M. Smith | 414,430 | 108 | 69 | 123 | 1326 |
Adam Greenwood | 190,180 | 94 | 55 | 127 | 2089 |
Nate Oman | 186,900 | 106 | 65 | 127 | 1483 |
Jonathan Green | 173,963 | 102 | 67 | 105 | 786 |
Russell Arben Fox | 150,619 | 62 | 27 | 90 | 1068 |
Ardis Parshall | 141,913 | 93 | 50 | 115 | 1136 |
Matt Evans | 94,489 | 103 | 70 | 121 | 1281 |
Dave Banack | 94,120 | 120 | 81 | 134 | 1607 |
Patricia Karamesines | 92,887 | 130 | 70 | 186 | 1780 |
Kathryn Lynard Soper | 90,915 | 112 | 71 | 126 | 1230 |
Frank McIntyre | 64,464 | 110 | 68 | 154 | 2481 |
Rosalynde Welch | 43,265 | 95 | 69 | 95 | 940 |
Wilfried Decoo | 34,447 | 96 | 73 | 84 | 404 |
Jim F. | 31,313 | 125 | 74 | 150 | 1169 |
Ben Huff | 30,466 | 143 | 84 | 180 | 1484 |
Curtis DeGraw | 20,798 | 82 | 47 | 92 | 626 |
Mormon Mentality | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Devyn S. | 270,637 | 113 | 72 | 156 | 2449 |
DKL | 157,216 | 88 | 48 | 110 | 1089 |
annegb | 147,121 | 92 | 56 | 107 | 1281 |
Margaret Young | 97,803 | 119 | 79 | 125 | 914 |
danithew | 82,664 | 80 | 57 | 85 | 800 |
Dan Ellsworth | 77,796 | 110 | 70 | 138 | 1363 |
Matt B | 72,996 | 100 | 60 | 112 | 1213 |
a Random John | 72,838 | 74 | 49 | 85 | 847 |
john f. | 53,209 | 107 | 64 | 124 | 1357 |
Tagore | 51,590 | 70 | 49 | 70 | 596 |
Proud Daughter of Eve | 37,728 | 95 | 61 | 110 | 824 |
Wayne L. | 24,434 | 158 | 105 | 175 | 1070 |
Amira | 5,947 | 73 | 43 | 82 | 479 |
New Cool Thang | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Geoff J | 334,710 | 123 | 87 | 124 | 1251 |
Matt W. | 213,097 | 104 | 70 | 115 | 1739 |
Jacob J | 124,373 | 126 | 91 | 126 | 1415 |
Blake | 78,945 | 147 | 99 | 185 | 1856 |
Kristen J | 11,103 | 62 | 42 | 64 | 408 |
Mormon Mommy Wars | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Heather O. | 267,676 | 73 | 53 | 75 | 857 |
The Wiz | 156,383 | 67 | 45 | 74 | 770 |
Tracy M | 103,449 | 84 | 53 | 105 | 2187 |
Hollywood | 74,443 | 75 | 56 | 69 | 641 |
Millennial Star | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Geoff B | 316,920 | 124 | 78 | 146 | 2090 |
Ivan Wolfe | 45,861 | 107 | 71 | 143 | 1621 |
John Mansfield | 43,249 | 93 | 56 | 112 | 1266 |
Brian Duffin | 25,509 | 75 | 47 | 90 | 765 |
Kevin Burtt (The Baron) | 15,527 | 96 | 70 | 95 | 661 |
Keller | 14,894 | 191 | 95 | 273 | 1574 |
Sarah | 5,864 | 101 | 54 | 101 | 415 |
Zelophehad’s Daughters | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Lynnette | 132,189 | 150 | 108 | 170 | 1915 |
Seraphine | 112,182 | 146 | 115 | 126 | 943 |
Kiskilili | 96,035 | 171 | 123 | 166 | 1317 |
Eve | 55,797 | 122 | 82 | 128 | 1161 |
Vada | 50,992 | 153 | 118 | 132 | 818 |
Ziff | 47,187 | 134 | 94 | 124 | 817 |
[ZD] | 9,322 | 114 | 78 | 106 | 558 |
Faith Promoting Rumor | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
TT | 137,390 | 131 | 86 | 152 | 1296 |
lxxluthor | 70,920 | 141 | 89 | 165 | 1336 |
smallaxe | 56,513 | 135 | 101 | 127 | 1013 |
Mogget | 29,476 | 111 | 68 | 128 | 959 |
Nitsav | 27,810 | 75 | 41 | 85 | 430 |
jupiterschild | 24,969 | 136 | 82 | 130 | 673 |
Chris H. | 12,209 | 123 | 80 | 147 | 1002 |
Nine Moons | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Rusty | 142,149 | 76 | 46 | 97 | 1178 |
Don Clifton | 52,486 | 89 | 63 | 86 | 575 |
Tom | 50,819 | 92 | 64 | 89 | 503 |
Susan M | 34,043 | 76 | 46 | 86 | 616 |
Lamonte | 30,776 | 98 | 78 | 86 | 544 |
Seth | 26,276 | 81 | 54 | 89 | 645 |
CJ Douglass | 22,709 | 114 | 74 | 150 | 1662 |
Exponent II | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Name | Words in Comments on their Posts | ||||
Total | Mean | Median | Std dev | Max | |
Caroline | 101,468 | 128 | 99 | 119 | 873 |
amelia | 67,617 | 150 | 110 | 145 | 937 |
Deborah | 53,028 | 99 | 64 | 107 | 1018 |
jana | 40,165 | 117 | 84 | 111 | 900 |
Maria | 32,980 | 128 | 98 | 120 | 919 |
Dora | 28,358 | 150 | 125 | 121 | 868 |
AmyB | 27,525 | 129 | 107 | 93 | 501 |
EmilyCC | 23,338 | 96 | 69 | 98 | 872 |
Brooke | 6,912 | 86 | 53 | 87 | 440 |
Okay, that’s it. I’m sorry I didn’t have any fun plots this time. I hope those of you who blog at one of the blogs in my sample at least had fun looking your own numbers up in the tables.
Update: I’ve now combined J. Daniel Crawford’s stats across his posts at BCC and FPR.
Awesome.
(now I’m bringing down your comment mean…)
Wow – that’s a lot of data and information to think about.
Thank you so much for putting this together.
Thanks for doing this analysis – it is very impressive. How many hours did this take?
Ha! And here I was worried about being too long winded! I think that DMI Dave wrote about the perfect blog post only being a few paragraphs. Perhaps I internalized his advice without meaning to.
Or perhaps my posts are just packed with meaning.
Unlikely.
Ziff,
So you know (as it might change some of this), I am J. Daniel Crawford.
Ziff, Your data is incomplete. I don’t see my insightful and brilliant guest post at Z’s Daughters reflected in these statistics. I know that post would have put me over the top as Best Blogger. Oh, wait, I’m confusing this post with the Niblets results.
After this post, I think you have well earned the title of The Official Numbers Wonk of the Bloggernacle 🙂
Very impressive, Ziff, and thanks for the link to my “instant permablogger” post, which I had entirely forgotten about. I would never have guessed I put up 157 DMI posts in 2007, but I’ll take your word for it.
I’m dizzy from all this — so far all I’ve absorbed is that I’m wordy, deviant, and mean. Or something. But thanks for something fun to look at and consider.
very cool. Thanks!
Incredibly interesting. I’m wondering what conclusions you will end up at, and what you think the numbers really ‘mean’ in terms of relationships between post length/frequency, readership, and blog development.
Rusty,
I wouldn’t worry about the comment mean. I think he’s going to do just find on the length of post metrics.
Rusty, go ahead and pull my comment mean down! I think this type of post probably falls (loosely) into the same FYE category I suggested might be used to describe some ExII posts. It’s not really discussion-provoking, more just to give you something to read that might be interesting. (Also, in truth, I’m really just going for longest post of 2008. When I put this into Word, it said it was 7179 words.)
John C., sorry, I should have known! I tried to make all the connections across blogs that I knew of, but clearly I wasn’t complete. I’ll merge your stats together under BCC when I get the chance.
a Random John, I think your “packed with meaning” explanation is completely reasonable. Better to write posts that get to the point than long, rambly ones. I think it was Lynnette I talked to recently who suggested that some of our posts get out of control in length when we over-write them, trying to imagine every possible response to them and write the responses into the post. 🙂
Sorry, ECS. I think your guest post got lost here because it was posted under the ZD admin account. But I certainly agree that you should have won best blogger. Well, either you or Eve. 😉
Ardis, on the bright side at least you’re a standard deviant, and not one of those weird deviants.
Steve, that’s a great question. This all certainly would be more interesting if I could work toward some conclusion. I know I’m taking the wimp’s way out in saying this, but I think that to get a really good idea of what these things mean for how blogs develop, I would have to collect longitudinal data, and look at T&S, BCC, FMH, etc. from their beginnings, or at least across a few years. For this sample, I intentionally chose only blogs that had existed for all of 2007, so they probably didn’t change a whole lot over the year.
Ziff, I suspect your right about needing a deeper sample to come to any real conclusions — and even then you’re just looking at posts, not comments or intangible community-building items that can contribute to blog growth or popularity.
I can tell you anecdotally that my posts have gotten shorter over time; it’s probably painfully obvious that stuff like the Friday Firestorms are there, at least in part, to ensure that I at least post something on a regular basis. My reading of how other major bloggers have progressed over time tends to follow similar trends.
Wow. wow- I don’t even know what to DO with all that! Thanks for pulling this together
er, you’re right. Sheesh!!
Holy smack! Thanks for the fun numbers!
So what is the verdict, should I concentrate on writing shorter entries? Some of the lack of comments on my posts were due to M* being in a downturn. I have 8 posts on the FAIR blog and I average between 10-11 comments but I have reduced my average post length to 930 words.
Keller, good question, but I’m not in a position to answer it well. I’m sure different readers prefer different things. As a frequent bloggernacle reader, I can tell you that I like to read a variety of post types depending on my mood–personal essay types, short conversation starters, inflammatory argument inciters, longer research pieces, FYE posts, all of it. I guess for someone like me, the joy of the bloggernacle is that there is so much interesting material of different kinds being written all the time.
From the perspective of a writer seeking an interested audience or a reader seeking interesting material, another advantage of the bloggernacle is that there’s a lot of interconnection between the blogs. I suspect this makes it easier for readers to find the kind of writing they like most and writers to find the audience they’re looking for. So if any one person writes a particular kind of stuff, and anyone in the bloggernacle is interested, reader and writer will probably eventually meet up.
Okay, I’ve now combined stats for J. Daniel Crawford across posts at BCC and FPR. Thanks, John, for alerting me to this error.
So, does anyone else want to fess up about using multiple names and confusing my feeble brain? Are Steve Evans and Matt Evans the same person? Is Kevin Barney really fMhLisa’s alter ego? 🙂
Very cool, Ziff. It’s nice to know that I am officially the wordiest person in the bloggernacle. Yay, me! 🙂
I do wonder to what extent this is affected by the informal T&S rule of closing comments after #100 in most cases. If we didn’t have that rule — I guess I might have even _more_ than 470,000 words in comments to my posts. Yikes.
Is there an easy way to track the major commenters? I.e., “DKL made 2000 comments, Julie made 3000, Stapley made 2500” or the like? That’s probably too complicated, isn’t it?
I bet the posts with the most comments deal with sex, (including same-sex marriage), gender roles, or some kind of complaint.
Ziff, don’t forget to add in stats for HP.
ECS, you’re not supposed to reveal the FMH secret!
Kaimi, I’m sure you’re right that y’all’s closing comments noticeably reduces the numbers you get. Possibly dramatically, since it’s usually only the posts that look like they’re on their way to 200 comments that get closed.
I actually do have data on who made the comments, but I’m only just starting to look at it. You’re right that it’s a lot more complicated. Much of the problem is that while people post under very consistent names, they often comment using several different names and I’m not sure how well I’m going to do at combining them. I may find that I just have the same problem I did with J. Daniel Crawford’s post data, but now over and over.
Speaking of that, I see I somehow still have him listed as two separate people at BCC. Sorry JDC! I really will get this right eventually. Perhaps I should give up on the whole idea of analyzing comments if I have this much trouble with posts. 🙂
Eric, if I understand right, you’re referring to another of JDC’s aliases? Sorry to be thick-headed if it’s something else. Anyway, thanks for warning me; I don’t think he’s posted under that name, although I know he’s commented using it.
If only this included 2008 posts this comment would have been #2 on the list of single longest comments with 2,815 words. Next year I guess.
I just quadruple-checked all my posts, and I tell you, I did not write 10,472 words. I wrote 10,474 words. I demand that you change your table to more accurately represent my Bloggernacle contributions!
AB
Many apologies, Aaron B. I should have been more explicit about the error in my measurement method. I estimate that you wrote 10,472 ± 8,229 words. 🙂
Jacob, you all really do attract gigantic comments at NCT! I’ll be sure to make a note of that one if I have the energy to do something similar to this next year.
Wow, I’m sure that took way too much time. 😛
This is pretty interesting data.
What it basically says to me is that there are about 50 people that comment a great deal on a lot of blogs, maybe 100 more that occasionally comment, and probably about 500 to 1000 readers that repeatedly log in to multiple different blogs. Not the 10s of thousands of readers that has been alluded to on so many other blogs.
What do you think about readership numbers?
Good question. Certainly you’re right that, in these data, quite a small number of people wrote the vast majority of the posts.
But there are several qualifiers to consider.
First, I’m sorry that it’s not very clear in this avalanche of tables, but I’m only looking here at posts, not comments. All the numbers of comments stuff is listed by who wrote the post, not who wrote the comments. I have data on who wrote the comments, and I hope to look at that soon and post about it. I expect that a far larger group of people comment regularly than post regularly.
Second, I don’t have any data on page visits to figure out how many people lurk without commenting. Based on how many people comment here and there, prefacing their comments with “I’m going to de-lurk briefly” I think it’s probably quite a bit larger than the number of people who comment. This also matches my own experience. I comment here at ZD fairly regularly, but at the other blogs I read, I mostly just lurk and I hardly ever comment.
Finally, my sample is pretty limited. Sure, it includes the big three (FMH, BCC, and T&S), but it ignores far more blogs than it includes. For example, I didn’t include any of the following group blogs: Blog Segullah, The Cultural Hall, FAIR blog, Feast on the Word Blog, Juvenile Instructor, Mormon Matters, A Motley Vision, Our Thoughts, Sunstone Blog, Tales from the Crib, or Waters of Mormon. And that’s not all of the ones I missed. Plus, all of this doesn’t even consider the even greater number of solo blogs.
So I don’t know. I wouldn’t be surprised if the total number of readers were in the tens of thousands, but my data will likely only show how many people comment in my limited sample. As with the posts, it will probably be a fairly small number of people who write most of the comments. But again, I can’t tell how many people are lurking and reading them.
Devyn and Jonathan, you asked how long this took. I honestly have no idea. It took lots of time, but I enjoy this type of stuff so much that when I’m working on it, I’m blissfully unaware of the world around me, much to my wife’s dismay. 🙂
Ziff,
This stuff is awesome! It’s like the opposite of the Niblets, based purely on data.
Thanks for putting this together.
Now I’m wondering if I can get busy and beat Heather down in ’08? How dare she write nearly twice as many posts as me!
I’m actually embarrassed about how little I understand these numbers. I seem to vaguely recall once knowing what means and medians and deviations meant, though I can’t remember when i learned it. I need a statistics for idiots book so that I can understand this stuff.
Good question, Lisa. Sorry I didn’t explain more clearly. The mean is just the average. So for example in the first FMH table, you wrote 31,396 words in 106 posts, so the mean is just 31,396 divided by 106, or about 296.
The median is the middle value when they’re all lined up in order. I don’t have the numbers in front of me, but of your 106 posts, maybe the shortest was 50 words or something, and then there were some in the 60’s and 70’s and up to the 100’s and 200’s and 300’s all the way up to your longest of 1313 words. The middle post that list is 223 words long.
The standard deviation is (roughly) a measure of how far your post lengths are from your average post length. So if it’s high, you write long posts and medium posts and short posts. If it’s low, you write posts that are all of a similar length. There’s a link to the Wikipedia article on the standard deviation from the words “std dev” in the heading of every table if you want to read more.
Thanks Jessawhy, Kevin, Tracy, ECS, Steve, Dave, Devyn, Rusty, danithew, and anyone else I might have missed who had nice things to say. I’m glad you enjoyed my number crunching. Thanks so much for the positive feedback.